The Best Cheesecake Ever
December 22, 2008 This is a cheesecake. (Forgive the shoddy slicing job; I pretty much forsook any amount of patience and just dove in.) This cheesecake is not just any cheesecake however.
It's the best cheesecake I've ever eaten.
I'm not kidding. Don't believe me? Well, that's just rude. But ask my friends. Emily couldn't think of anything to say, so she just giggled and screamed "Yaaaay!!!!" after her first bite. I think that sums it up. It's the perfect cheesecake. Full of flavor, light texture, not terribly hard to make, and the perfect thing to take to the family Christmas dinner. Where did it come from? Chaos in the Kitchen kindly shared her secret family recipe for the cheesecake and the crust. Give this chick a medal.
I've made a couple of changes just to suit my family's taste (less sugar, more lemon, more crust), but you will never make another cheesecake again. I guarantee it. The best cheesecake recipe EVER.
The Best Cheesecake Ever
The crust...
- 1 cup plus 2 tbsp. graham cracker crumbs
- 1/3 cup plus 1 tbsp. brown sugar
- 5 tbsp. melted butter
Mix the ingredients together in a small bowl. A fork worked pretty well to break up the brown sugar. Cover a 10-inch springform pan (a round pan made of two pieces - the bottom and sort of a thick hoop with a buckle that can be taken off once the cake is cooled) with heavy duty aluminum foil so the bottom is covered and it goes mostly up the outside of the pan. This is to keep the water out during cooking. Why water? That comes later.
Press the crust to evenly cover the bottom of the pan and a little up the sides. Just use your hand and be gentle; don't overthink it. You shouldn't see the bottom of the pan; that means you have a hole in your crust. And that's just sad. And, yes, that is my real skin color.
Bake the crust in a preheated 325 degree oven for 5-8 minutes. You just want a slight golden color. Remember, the crust will bake again with the cheesecake filling, so there's no need to bake it to death.
While the crust bakes and cools, work on the filling.
- 2 1/2 bars of cream cheese (20 oz.) left out at room temperature to let soften
- 1 1/2 cups of granulated (white) sugar
- 2 t. vanilla extract
- 3 large eggs
- 3 T. cornstarch
- 2 cups heavy cream or heavy whipping cream (whichever your store has; same difference pretty much)
- 1/2 tsp. salt
- 2 tbsp. lemon juice
- 1 tsp. lemon zest
In a mixing bowl (with a paddle attachment if you have a stand mixture), mix together the cream cheese, sugar, and vanilla until it's combined and creamy looking. Next add the eggs one at a time. Make sure the first egg is incorporated before adding the next one. Then add the cornstarch and cream, and mix it together until the cream is mostly worked in. Then turn the speed to high and beat for several minutes until the mixture is nice and fluffy. Last, add the lemon juice and zest, and mix until it's just combined.
Now let your eyes roll into the back of your head as you lick the beaters. Now get a spatula and scrape the filling into the cooled crust. Now lick the spatula. You're making it easier to wash your dishes, so don't skip these licking steps. Unless of course you're pregnant or have a thing with eating dough with raw eggs. (Just covering my bases.)
Now comes the part that weirds people out but doesn't need to. The water bath. It helps keep the cheesecake moist and from cracking. Get your big roasting pan from your Thanksgiving turkey or just get a big casserole dish. Set your springform pan inside, and carefully pour hot water into the pan until it's about halfway up the sides. I say carefully because you don't want it to splash into the cheesecake... like I did the first time. Now carefully slide the pan into the 325 oven for about an hour.
Here comes another tricky part. How to know when a cheesecake is done. It's different than most baked goods in that it should be jiggly. Really jiggly. It'll firm up as it cools down and chills in the fridge, so don't be afraid to pull it out of the oven before you think you're supposed to. Here's a tip I read somewhere. A good definition of jiggly is that it should jiggle like Jello, not wave like water.
So once the cheesecake is jiggly like Jello, turn off the oven, and leave the pan inside with the door open for about 15 minutes. Then pull it out, and let it cool for awhile. After an hour or so, take the cheesecake out of the water and set it on a towel to dry the bottom a bit. Carefully remove the foil, and then cover the top with plastic wrap and chill in the fridge overnight or for at least four hours. Serve to your friends, and be prepared for them to offer you their firstborn in exchange for a piece to take home. I'd be ready with a more appropriate counter-offer.
Kendra |
33 Comments |
Sweet Treats 





Reader Comments (33)
Don't worry, it looks delicious... both of them :D you're doing great!
Wow! If I knew it would look that good I might have tried it in a waterbath sooner. The pictures are fabulous, and the cheesecake looks perfect. I have to make two of these this week so maybe I will try the waterbath and see how it goes. Thanks so much for trying my recipe, I am so happy it worked out so wonderfully for you!
Thanks for sharing this! The mister is a cheesaholic, while I don't eat cheese at all. I'm sure he'd love this! And since I won't even get to taste it, I'll believe you when you say it's the best cheesecake ever! :P
mmm...can't wait to try this! cheesecake is my absolute favorite! it's what i get for my birthday instead of traditional bday cake. thanks for sharing.
I cannot wait to try this recipe! I ate of a homemade cheesecake years ago that I still dream about and forever have looked for a good recipe! Thank-you!
To cut a cheescake take a long knife, at least the length of the diameter, heat it under a warm tap, then put the entire length of the knife into the cake and slowly pull straight out, not up! rinse the knife and repeat. Keep it hot!
mmmmm cheesecake! Both the recipe and your website look fantastic.
This sounds very good - I've never made a cheesecake, but find myself wanting to after reading this. But I don't have any idea how long it should cook in its water bath (or at what temperature. It may be in the instructions somewhere, but I can't find it.
Help.
Brad
It says the water temp should be "hot", Brad, and that it goes in for about and hour..;) umm.. cheesecake..
That looks like the best cheesecake ever!!!! Time to hit the kitchen - thanks :)
I've tried many a cheesecake recipes. I'll give this one a try as well, and thanks for the waterbath and "jiggly" part. No other recipe has suggested that.
This is certainly worth a try! I'll feedback the reactions!
Hey, im spanish so can anyone tell me what this means "3 T. cornstarch" "2 t. vanilla extract", i mean the "T" what do they stand for?, i cant figure it out.. :) thx
Hi Nessa! The big "T" stands for tablespoon and the little "t" stands for teaspoon. Sorry for the confusion; hope this helps!
I made this last night for my wife. It was pretty good, however, I'd recommend leaving out the lemon juice and lemon zest, or maybe just using 1/2 t lemon juice. I used the full 2 T of lemon juice, and it made it taste like a lemon cheesecake, which I didn't want at all. I'm going to remake it using no lemon juice and no lemon zest and see how it turns out.
Also, I'm going to double the amount of graham crackers for a thicker crust. Mine was very thin. I like a thick crust on my cheesecake.
How does one make this cheesecake maybe a bit thicker? It fell apart when I went to cut into it.
Great recipe. I'm definately going to have to try this one. Maybe with some summer berries? Yum!
Use a stainless steel measuring cup to smooth out the crust. The crumbs won't stick to it and it is great for getting the crust up on the side of the springform pan
Glad to see that you use the water bath. That is a secret many people don't know. It really keeps the cheesecake moist.
I just bought a springform pan, and I've had this recipe in the back of my mind since I got it! It looks delicious...i also have some nice blueberries that i might reduce down into a sauce...lemony cheesecake with blueberry sauce sounds just perfect right about now!
-amy
http://asliceoflohrpie.blogspot.com
I'm a cheesecake lover and am always on the lookout for a new good recipe. I like the ratio of cream cheese to cream in this one. Great photos, too!
I stumbled onto your blog and I just wanted to say that your cheesecake looks and sounds fantastic. Also, you appologize for the shoddy cutting job on the first image of the cheesecake - I just wanted to tell you that it's more artistic the way that it is. I think it makes it look more like something you want to drive right into rather than the clean neat slices of most cheesecake shots.
I love, love, loooove cheesecake. I'm excited to try it and am drooling over the possibilities of toppings. Thanks, I'll let you know how it goes! I've got a handful of recipes on my blog, not nearly as lovely of pictures as yours but they taste like heaven...
www.oneshetwoshe.blogspot
I'll be back!
Mariel
Try replacing the sugar with vanilla sugar. It is sugar that has a whole vanilla bean in with the sugar. The sugar tastes great! I got some at Juliet Mae spices online.
my mom and dad both love cheesecake, and this looks like its right up their alley! thanks for sharing this! it'll be a great addition to my mom's celebration for mothers day!
this is best receipe ever i tried
Sound and looks delicious, will try the recipe - thanks for sharing!